Four Color Comic
4Four Color Comic
WELCOME BACK

Welcome back

Sign in to access your comic vault.

New to Four Color Comic?
Start free • Collector from $1.99/month
4Four Color ComicYour collection • your legacy
Membership
YOUR LIVING COMIC VAULT

Know what you own.
Know what you earned.

Track every cover, value your collection, move sold books into a permanent sales ledger, and see realized profit at a glance.

0 active books$0.00 tracked value

Top unrealized gains

Based on current working values

Portfolio mix

Value, cost basis, gain, and book count
Balanced

Highest-priority books

Collection snapshot

Collection

Prices can be edited directly. Use Edit for every book detail. ● Changes update every tab automatically.
DISCOVER SOMETHING NEW

Comic Fact of the Day

Loading today’s comic fact…

Built-in daily fact library No AI • No tokens

Why this is great

A little piece of collector culture

Loading today’s collector context…

Four Color takeaway

The hobby is bigger than the book

Loading today’s Four Color takeaway…

Sold books

A permanent sales ledger showing what each book cost, what it sold for, and the realized profit or loss.

Suggested Price

Automatic market estimate
Automatic

Four Color Comic automatically calculates and updates the Suggested Price using available market information. The displayed Suggested Price is an estimate and can change as market conditions change.

Pricing note: Suggested Price is an estimate, not a guaranteed sale price. Rare variants and thinly traded books may require additional collector research.

How to use Suggested Price

Collector guide
  1. Use Suggested Price as a quick starting estimate for the comic.
  2. Keep your own Market Price separate when your research or knowledge differs.
  3. Portfolio P/L uses your Market Price when entered; otherwise it uses Suggested Price.
  4. Review rare variants, signatures, unusual grades, and low-volume books manually before buying or selling.
Suggested Price = Four Color Comic automatic market estimate

Pricing review

Select a comic to review its current Suggested Price.
Grading reference

Four Color Comic Book Grading Reference

Updated August 2026 — CGC, CBCS, PGX, and Overstreet-style raw grading

Purpose

This guide is intended as a practical reference for estimating the condition of raw comic books and for interpreting third-party grades from CGC, CBCS, and PGX.

Comic grading is inherently subjective. A numerical grade is an informed opinion based on the total condition of the book, not a mechanical defect-counting formula. Two experienced graders—or even the same certification company on separate submissions—may reasonably differ by a grading increment.

For Four Color estimates, visible defects should be evaluated against the grade descriptions below. When photographs do not show the back cover, spine, interior, staples, centerfold, page quality, restoration, or other relevant areas, the result should be stated as an estimated range, not an exact guaranteed grade.

1. Standard Comic Grading Scale+

CGC, CBCS, and PGX all use the familiar 10-point comic-book grading framework. The commonly encountered numerical grades are:

Grade Abbreviation General Description
10.0 GM Gem Mint
9.9 MT Mint
9.8 NM/M Near Mint/Mint
9.6 NM+ Near Mint+
9.4 NM Near Mint
9.2 NM- Near Mint-
9.0 VF/NM Very Fine/Near Mint
8.5 VF+ Very Fine+
8.0 VF Very Fine
7.5 VF- Very Fine-
7.0 FN/VF Fine/Very Fine
6.5 FN+ Fine+
6.0 FN Fine
5.5 FN- Fine-
5.0 VG/FN Very Good/Fine
4.5 VG+ Very Good+
4.0 VG Very Good
3.5 VG- Very Good-
3.0 GD/VG Good/Very Good
2.5 GD+ Good+
2.0 GD Good
1.8 GD- Good-
1.5 FR/GD Fair/Good
1.0 FR Fair
0.5 PR Poor

Important company-specific note

The shared numerical scale does not mean CGC, CBCS, and PGX will necessarily assign the same grade to the same comic. Each company applies its own internal grading judgment, restoration detection, label policies, signature policies, and treatment of unusual defects.

CGC also uses non-numeric designations such as NG (No Grade), PG (Page), and CVR (Cover) for certain incomplete items or individual components rather than forcing them into the 0.5–10.0 numerical scale.


2. Broad Grade Bands+
  • Near Mint (NM): 9.2–9.8
  • Very Fine (VF): 7.5–9.0
  • Fine (FN): 5.5–7.0
  • Very Good (VG): 3.5–5.0
  • Good (GD): 1.8–3.0
  • Fair (FR): 1.0–1.5
  • Poor (PR): 0.5

Grades of 9.9 and 10.0 are exceptional certification-level grades and should not normally be predicted for a raw comic from photographs. For raw-photo grading, 9.8 should generally be treated as the practical ceiling unless the book can be examined extremely closely in hand.


3. Grade Standards and Typical Allowable Defects+

No single defect automatically determines a final grade in every case. Grade depends on severity, quantity, location, eye appeal, structural integrity, age, manufacturing characteristics, and the accumulation of defects.

A repeated minor defect can become a major downgrade when accumulated across the book.

Gem Mint — 10.0+

An essentially flawless collectible.

Typical expectations:

  • No evidence of handling wear.
  • No meaningful manufacturing defects.
  • Excellent registration, cut, corners, spine, surface, and gloss.
  • For CGC, only White page quality is permitted at 10.0.

Four Color rule: Do not estimate 10.0 from ordinary photographs.


Mint — 9.9+

Nearly indistinguishable from a 10.0.

Typical expectations:

  • No handling defects.
  • At most an extremely minor manufacturing imperfection.
  • Exceptional corners, spine, gloss, surface, and structure.

Four Color rule: Do not estimate 9.9 from ordinary photographs.


Near Mint/Mint — 9.8+

A nearly perfect copy with negligible handling or manufacturing defects.

Typical allowable characteristics may include:

  • One or a very small number of extremely minor spine stresses.
  • Extremely slight corner blunting.
  • A tiny non-color-breaking bend or indentation.
  • Very minor production imperfections.
  • Strong gloss and excellent eye appeal.

A visible color-breaking crease, significant corner damage, notable spine wear, staining, tears, or obvious surface wear normally prevents a 9.8.


Near Mint+ — 9.6+

A very high-grade copy with several very minor defects.

Possible defects include:

  • A few tiny spine stresses.
  • Minor non-color-breaking bends or dents.
  • Slight corner wear.
  • Small production imperfections.
  • Very light surface wear visible under reflected light.

The overall appearance should remain extremely sharp.


Near Mint — 9.4+

A very well-preserved copy showing minor wear or small manufacturing/handling defects.

Possible defects include:

  • A small accumulation of minor spine stresses.
  • Minor corner blunting.
  • A few small dents or dimples.
  • Small non-color-breaking bends.
  • Slight surface wear.
  • Very small color-breaking stress may be tolerated depending on the rest of the book.

The book should still have excellent overall eye appeal.


Near Mint- — 9.2+

A high-grade copy with somewhat more visible minor wear than a 9.4.

Possible defects include:

  • Several spine stresses, including limited color break.
  • Minor corner wear.
  • Small bends or folds.
  • Light surface impressions.
  • Slight handling wear.
  • Minor production flaws.

The book remains clean, flat, attractive, and structurally sound.


Very Fine/Near Mint — 9.0+

A very well-preserved comic with good eye appeal and a noticeable accumulation of minor defects.

Possible defects include:

  • Several spine stresses.
  • Limited color-breaking ticks.
  • Minor corner wear.
  • Small bends, folds, or dents.
  • Light surface wear.
  • Minor handling or production defects.

Very Fine+ — 8.5+

An attractive copy with either one moderate defect or a number of small defects.

Possible defects include:

  • Light accumulation of color-breaking spine stress.
  • Minor corner wear.
  • Moderate non-color-breaking bend.
  • Small crease.
  • Light surface wear.
  • Minor edge wear.

Very Fine — 8.0+

An attractive, well-preserved comic with a moderate defect or an accumulation of smaller defects.

Possible defects include:

  • Several color-breaking spine ticks.
  • Minor-to-moderate corner wear.
  • Small bends or folds.
  • Light creasing.
  • Minor edge wear.
  • Small surface abrasions or impressions.

Very Fine- — 7.5+

An above-average copy with a moderate defect or accumulation of small defects.

Possible defects include:

  • More obvious spine stress.
  • Limited creasing.
  • Minor edge tears.
  • Moderate corner wear.
  • Light reading wear.
  • Noticeable but not severe surface wear.

Fine/Very Fine — 7.0+

An above-average comic that may have one major defect or an accumulation of smaller defects.

Possible defects include:

  • Moderate spine stress and color break.
  • Noticeable corner wear.
  • Small tears.
  • Longer creases.
  • Minor spine roll.
  • Minor staining or residue.
  • Moderate handling wear.

Fine+ — 6.5+

An above-average comic with a major defect plus smaller defects, or a significant accumulation of minor defects.

Possible defects include:

  • Moderate spine wear.
  • Small spine split.
  • Moderate crease.
  • Minor staining.
  • Impacted corner.
  • Moderate foxing.
  • Small tears or edge wear.

Fine — 6.0+

A slightly above-average copy showing definite wear.

Possible defects include:

  • Moderate accumulation of spine stresses.
  • Color-breaking creases.
  • Minor spine roll.
  • Small spine split.
  • Minor water spotting or residue.
  • Impacted corner.
  • Moderate foxing.
  • General handling wear.

Fine- — 5.5+

A slightly above-average comic with several moderate defects.

The book remains complete, readable, and reasonably attractive, but wear is obvious.


Very Good/Fine — 5.0+

An average collectible with several moderate defects.

Possible defects include:

  • Spine roll.
  • Noticeable creases.
  • Small tears.
  • Moderate staining.
  • Significant spine stress.
  • Moderate corner and edge wear.
  • Partial staple detachment may occur depending on severity and the remainder of the book.

Very Good+ — 4.5+

A slightly below-average copy with multiple moderate defects.

Eye appeal is reduced, but the comic remains solidly collectible.


Very Good — 4.0+

A below-average copy with significant wear.

Possible defects include:

  • Spine roll.
  • Approximately 1/2"–1" spine splits or comparable tears.
  • Cover or centerfold detached at one staple.
  • Oxidation/discoloration.
  • Moderate water staining.
  • Heavy creasing.
  • General surface and edge wear.

Very Good- — 3.5+

A below-average comic with several major defects or a substantial accumulation of moderate defects.

Structural wear may be significant but the comic remains broadly intact and readable.


Good/Very Good — 3.0+

A heavily handled collectible with several moderate-to-major defects.

Possible defects include:

  • Large creases.
  • Tears.
  • Significant spine wear or splitting.
  • Detached components.
  • Heavy staining.
  • Significant oxidation.
  • Substantial surface wear.

Good+ — 2.5+

A heavily worn comic with multiple moderate-to-major defects.

The book should remain identifiable and generally readable, though appearance and structure may be poor.


Good — 2.0+

A comic with extensive wear and numerous moderate-to-major defects.

Possible defects include:

  • Large tears.
  • Long creases.
  • Cover or centerfold detachment.
  • Significant spine splitting.
  • Heavy staining or water damage.
  • Heavy oxidation.
  • Substantial paper loss.

Completeness becomes especially important at this level.


Good- — 1.8+

Extensive handling and numerous major defects.

The comic may have serious structural problems while remaining sufficiently complete for a numeric grade.


Fair/Good — 1.5+

A very heavily worn comic with major defects and low eye appeal.

Possible defects include:

  • Large spine splits.
  • Severe tears.
  • Missing non-story portions.
  • Severe staining or water damage.
  • Missing back cover in some circumstances.
  • Extensive tape, residue, or deterioration.

Fair — 1.0+

A severely damaged but still identifiable comic.

A Fair comic may have:

  • Major structural damage.
  • Severe water or residue damage.
  • Mold or serious paper deterioration.
  • Large spine split.
  • Missing non-story material.
  • Missing back cover with sufficient remaining structure.
  • Extensive tears and creasing.

Story and art completeness is an important consideration.


Poor — 0.5+

A heavily defaced or severely incomplete comic.

Possible characteristics include:

  • Missing story or ad pages.
  • Major pieces missing.
  • Completely split spine.
  • Severe damage affecting readability.
  • Extensive brittleness or deterioration.
  • Serious structural failure.

A book may be too incomplete for some certification companies to assign a normal numeric grade.


4. Completeness and Qualified Grading+

Completeness must always be checked separately from cosmetic condition.

A visually beautiful comic can receive a very low grade if it is missing a page, coupon, centerfold, or other required component.

CGC Qualified Grade

CGC may assign a Qualified label to a comic with a significant defect that would otherwise dramatically reduce the grade. The assigned number reflects the book's condition as if the specified qualifying defect were not present, and the defect is explicitly noted on the label.

Example concept: a comic that visually presents around 6.0 but has a missing coupon may receive a Qualified 6.0 with the missing coupon identified rather than a much lower Universal grade.

Qualified grades must never be treated as directly equivalent in market value to Universal grades of the same number.

CBCS and PGX

CBCS and PGX may handle incompleteness and major defects differently from CGC's label system. Always read the certification label and grader notes rather than assuming the number alone tells the whole story.


5. CGC Label and Certification Categories+

Universal

A standard unrestored comic without a qualifying defect that requires a different certification category.

Qualified

Used when a significant defect is specifically called out and the numerical grade reflects the book while disregarding that qualifying defect.

Restored

CGC uses a restored designation when restoration has been detected. CGC separately evaluates the quality and quantity of restoration.

CGC Restoration Quality

  • A — Excellent
  • B — Fine
  • C — Poor

CGC Restoration Quantity

  • 1 — Slight
  • 2 — Slight/Moderate
  • 3 — Moderate
  • 4 — Moderate/Extensive
  • 5 — Extensive

A designation such as A-1 means high-quality, slight restoration; C-5 means poor-quality, extensive restoration.

Conserved

CGC distinguishes conservation from aesthetic restoration. Conservation is intended to improve structural or chemical stability rather than recreate appearance.

Examples recognized by CGC may include:

  • Tear seals.
  • Spine-split seals.
  • Reinforcement.
  • Piece reattachment.
  • Certain cover/interior cleaning.
  • Staple cleaning or replacement.
  • Some leaf casting.
  • De-acidification.

CGC conserved work must meet its A-quality / 1-quantity requirements.

Signature Series / Authenticated Signatures

CGC certification treatment depends on how the signature is authenticated.

CGC has witnessed Signature Series services and also offers signature authentication through JSA-related services. The exact label and notation should be read from the slab because witnessed, authenticated, qualified, and restored signed books can have different label treatments.

Pedigree

CGC uses a pedigree designation for books from collections formally recognized by CGC.

NG / PG / CVR

CGC may use:

  • NG — No Grade
  • PG — individual Page or Wrap
  • CVR — Cover

These designations are used for material that is too incomplete or component-specific for the normal numeric scale.


6. CBCS-Specific Considerations+

CBCS uses the standard comic grading framework but should not be assumed to apply every CGC label convention.

CBCS Signatures

CBCS distinguishes between signature services, including:

  • Authentic / witnessed signatures, when handled through an approved signing or witnessing process.
  • Verified signatures, for eligible unwitnessed signatures that pass CBCS's authentication process.

A pre-existing signature should never automatically be treated as authentic merely because a seller provides a Certificate of Authenticity. The certification label itself should be checked to determine whether CBCS authenticated or verified the signature.

CBCS Grader Notes

CBCS provides grader notes for certified books. When available, those notes are more useful than attempting to infer every defect from the front cover alone.

CBCS Check Mark

CBCS may use a Check Mark designation in rare cases when a comic has unusually strong visual presentation for the numerical grade despite a defect that limits the grade. The numerical grade remains the controlling grade.

Restoration / Alteration

CBCS evaluates comics for restoration and alteration. Do not assume CBCS follows CGC's purple/green label color conventions; read the text and notations on the CBCS label.


7. PGX-Specific Considerations+

PGX publishes its own comic grading guidelines based on the familiar Overstreet-style 10-point framework.

PGX states that its assigned grade is an opinion under its own grading standards; therefore a PGX grade should not be automatically assumed to cross over identically to CGC or CBCS.

PGX Signature Authentication

PGX offers authentication for signed and/or sketched books and identifies qualifying authenticated books through its Gold Label program.

When valuing a PGX-signed book, distinguish between:

  • A signature specifically authenticated/certified by PGX.
  • A signature merely present on the comic.
  • A third-party Certificate of Authenticity that is not itself the grading company's authentication.

PGX Restoration Detection

PGX advertises restoration detection as part of its certification services. Any restoration or alteration notation on the slab should be included when valuing or cataloging the book.


8. Page Quality+

Page quality is separate from the structural numerical grade and can materially affect desirability and, in some cases, the maximum grade available.

CGC's current published page-quality system includes designations such as:

  • White
  • Off-White to White
  • Off-White
  • Cream to Off-White
  • Cream
  • Light Tan combinations
  • Tan combinations
  • Dark Tan combinations
  • Brown combinations
  • Slightly Brittle
  • Brittle

Important CGC grade limitations include:

  • 10.0 requires White pages.
  • 9.9 requires at least Off-White to White.
  • With rare exception, 9.8 or better requires at least Off-White.
  • Light Tan to Off-White has a maximum grade of 8.5.
  • Tan to Off-White has a maximum grade of 7.5.
  • Slightly Brittle has a maximum grade of 6.5.
  • Brittle has a maximum grade of 3.5.

Photographs of only the cover cannot reliably determine interior page quality.


9. Pressing, Cleaning, Restoration, and Conservation+

These terms should not be used interchangeably.

Dry Cleaning

Careful non-aqueous surface cleaning can remove certain removable dirt or deposits. Whether a particular treatment is considered ordinary preparation, conservation, or restoration depends on the treatment performed and the certification company's standards.

Pressing

Standard non-restorative pressing is generally used to reduce certain bends, rippling, waviness, and impressions without adding material to the book.

Pressing cannot truly repair:

  • Color-breaking creases.
  • Missing paper.
  • Tears.
  • Scrapes that removed ink.
  • Stains that penetrated the paper.
  • Rust damage.
  • Significant structural damage.

A pressable defect should not be graded as though it has already been removed. Grade the comic as it currently exists, then separately estimate a possible post-press grade.

Restoration

Restoration involves treatment intended to return or enhance the appearance of damaged material and may include techniques such as:

  • Color touch.
  • Piece fill.
  • Re-glossing.
  • Recreated material.
  • Certain forms of cleaning or whitening.
  • Married pages or covers.
  • Other aesthetic repairs.

Conservation

Conservation focuses on preservation and structural stability. CGC formally distinguishes qualifying conservation from restoration.


10. Production Defects+

A production defect is created during manufacturing rather than subsequent handling.

Examples include:

  • Miswrap.
  • Off-center trimming.
  • Mis-cut edges.
  • Mis-folded spine.
  • Printer's crease.
  • Ink transfer.
  • Color-registration error.
  • Bindery tear.
  • Manufacturing indentation.
  • Missing or misplaced staple.
  • Untrimmed pages.

Production defects do not automatically mean "no downgrade." Their effect depends on severity, grade range, and the grading company's standards. Extremely high grades such as 9.9 and 10.0 allow almost no manufacturing imperfection.


11. Signatures, Writing, and Sketches+

Never assume writing on a comic is authenticated.

For raw books:

  • Identify the apparent signer only when reasonably clear.
  • State that authentication cannot be established from a photograph.
  • Distinguish market value for an authenticated signature from an unverified one when material.
  • A Certificate of Authenticity can support provenance but should not be treated as equivalent to third-party signature authentication unless the certification service itself recognizes it.

Writing unrelated to a collectible signature is graded according to severity, location, and overall effect.


12. Four Color Photo-Grading Protocol+

When estimating a raw comic from photographs:

  1. Identify the comic first. Confirm issue, printing, variant, edition, and obvious special features.
  2. Inspect the front cover for spine ticks, creases, tears, corner wear, surface dents, stains, abrasion, color loss, and production defects.
  3. Inspect the back cover whenever supplied.
  4. Inspect the spine and staples whenever visible.
  5. Check completeness only when interior images or trustworthy information are available.
  6. Do not infer White pages, intact centerfold, hidden tears, restoration, or complete interiors from a front-cover photograph.
  7. Give a reasonable grade range, normally spanning no more than a few grading increments when images are adequate.
  8. Identify the most likely grade within the range only when useful.
  9. Explain the visible defects driving the estimate.
  10. State whether defects appear potentially pressable, but grade the comic in its present condition.
  11. Never claim that a photo grade is equivalent to a guaranteed CGC, CBCS, or PGX result.
  12. For slabbed comics, use the actual visible certification company and grade instead of re-grading the book from the cover image.

Suggested confidence language

  • High confidence: clear front/back/spine images plus useful interior information.
  • Moderate confidence: clear front and back but limited spine/interior visibility.
  • Low confidence: one cover image, glare, bag distortion, poor resolution, or important areas obscured.

13. Quick Defect Reference+
Defect Typical Grading Importance
Non-color-breaking spine stress Minor at high grade when small/few
Color-breaking spine tick More significant; quantity matters
Non-color-breaking bend Often pressable; still counts before pressing
Color-breaking crease Permanent visible defect; stronger downgrade
Corner blunting Severity and color break determine impact
Tear Major relative to size/location
Spine split Significant structural defect
Detached staple Significant structural defect
Detached cover/centerfold Major defect
Missing page/coupon Completeness defect; can radically affect grade/category
Stain/water damage Significant; extent and penetration matter
Foxing Moderate-to-major depending on extent
Rust/migration Structural and cosmetic concern
Paper loss Significant; size/location matter
Color touch Restoration concern
Piece fill Restoration concern
Trimming Alteration/restoration concern for normal comic certification
Writing/signature Depends on authenticity, location, purpose, and severity
Manufacturing defect May still affect grade, particularly at ultra-high grades

14. Market Interpretation of Slab Grades+

A numerical grade should never be valued without also checking:

  • Certification company.
  • Label/category.
  • Restoration or conservation.
  • Qualified/incomplete notation.
  • Signature authentication status.
  • Page quality.
  • Variant/printing.
  • Certification notes where available.

A 9.4 Qualified, 9.4 Restored, 9.4 Conserved, and 9.4 Universal comic are not interchangeable market objects even though the numerical grade is the same.

Likewise, CGC, CBCS, and PGX copies at the same numerical grade may trade differently in the marketplace. Valuation should therefore use sold comparables from the same certification company and same certification type whenever possible.


15. Important Limitation+

This guide is a practical grading reference, not a claim to reproduce the confidential internal grading procedures of CGC, CBCS, or PGX.

Third-party grading companies retain discretion in evaluating accumulated defects, manufacturing flaws, restoration, conservation, incompleteness, signatures, page quality, and unusual books. Their published standards and the actual certification label take precedence when interpreting one of their slabs.


16. Four Color Defect Glossary+

The definitions below are written for this guide rather than reproduced from a retailer or grading-company glossary.

Bend — A curved or displaced area of paper that does not necessarily leave a sharp fold line or break printed color.

Bindery tear — A small tear created during manufacturing, commonly near the spine or trimmed edge. Its grading effect depends on size and severity.

Color break — Damage severe enough to fracture or remove printed ink, exposing lighter paper beneath.

Color touch — Added pigment used to disguise lost printed color. Certification services may classify intentional restorative color touch as restoration.

Cockling — A rippled or wavy paper surface, often associated with moisture, manufacturing, or treatment.

Crease — A distinct folded line in the paper. A crease that breaks color is normally more damaging to grade than a comparable non-color-breaking fold.

Denting / dimpling — Localized depressions in the cover surface without necessarily breaking ink or paper fibers.

Detached staple — A condition in which the cover or an interior wrap is no longer held by one of the staples.

Dust shadow — Uneven edge discoloration caused by part of a comic being exposed while another portion was protected during storage.

Fingerprints — Visible handling marks caused by oils or residue. Permanent ink disturbance is more serious than removable surface residue.

Fold — A defined linear deformation of the paper. If ink remains intact it is generally less severe than a color-breaking crease of similar size.

Foxing — Brown or rust-colored spotting associated with aging and environmental exposure. Extent and intensity matter.

Gloss loss — Reduction or interruption of the original surface sheen through wear, abrasion, cleaning, handling, or age.

Manufacturing defect — A flaw originating during printing, cutting, folding, binding, or distribution rather than later ownership. Examples include miswraps, printer creases, off-register color, and unusual trimming.

Moisture damage — Staining, waviness, swelling, stiffness, tide lines, adhesion, or other paper changes caused by water or high humidity.

Paper loss — Missing surface or structural paper caused by tears, chips, abrasion, tape pulls, insects, moisture, or other damage.

Reading crease — A crease near and roughly parallel to the spine produced when the cover is repeatedly opened or folded back.

Residue / soiling — Foreign material, dirt, adhesive, grime, or deposits remaining on the comic. Severity, removability, and resulting damage affect grade.

Spine roll — Curvature or displacement of the spine and page block, usually caused by repeated reading or storage pressure.

Spine split — Separation along the folded spine. Length, location, and whether pages or cover remain attached strongly affect grade.

Spine stress / tick — A short stress mark extending outward from the spine. Color-breaking ticks generally carry more weight than non-color-breaking ones.

Staple migration — Staining or deterioration spreading from corroded staples into nearby paper.

Staple pop — Paper tearing immediately around a staple while some attachment remains.

Staple rust — Corrosion on a staple; grading impact increases when rust transfers to or weakens the paper.

Subscription crease — A long fold associated with comics historically folded for mailing.

Tear — A separation of paper fibers. Size, placement, number, and whether material is missing determine its effect.

Wrap — One folded interior sheet that forms multiple sequential comic pages. Missing or detached wraps are completeness/structural issues.

Writing — Ink, pencil, marker, impressions, names, dates, doodles, or other added markings. Impact varies by amount, location, historical context, and whether a signature is authenticated.


17. Source and Independence Note+

This Four Color guide is an independently written collector reference. It uses the industry-standard numerical grade names because those terms are conventional identifiers, but the explanatory prose, defect summaries, workflow, and Four Color recommendations are original wording.

CGC, CBCS, PGX, Overstreet, and other grading-related names and marks belong to their respective owners. References to their programs are included only to explain publicly documented grading and certification practices. Four Color is not presented as affiliated with, endorsed by, or an official representative of those organizations.

Where a certification company's exact policy matters, users should consult that company's current published rules because services, labels, and policies can change.

Adaptive import assistance
Four Color Comic can adapt to patterns in your data and suggest how fields should be read. For the most accurate and reliable results, use the provided Four Color Comic template. Always review the detected fields and book details before completing an import because automated matches may be incomplete or incorrect.

Precision collection import

Upload the sheet once. Title, issue number, price, grade, raw/graded status and cover images are detected automatically.
Automatic
1Upload
2Analyze
3Review
4Import

Drop your collection sheet here

CSV, TSV, TXT, JSON, XLSX or XLS

Optional original cover photos
Choose JPG, PNG or WebP files. Uploaded photos take priority over stock covers and are matched by filename.
0 photos
Choose a collection file. Nothing is saved until you confirm the final import.
COLLECTION-FIRST MEMBERSHIP

Loading membership plans…

Plans scale by image storage, AI usage, marketplace access, and advanced tools.

Account

Update your username or change your password.
Supabase Auth
Account profile loads after sign-in.
Change password
Use at least eight characters.

Delete Collection

Permanently remove every comic, uploaded cover and related pricing record. Your login remains active.
Delete Collection
You will be asked to confirm before anything is removed.

Membership billing

Plans start at $1.99 per month. Stripe credentials are stored in server-side Netlify environment variables.
Setup pending
Billing enforcement
Checking app settings…
Run SUPABASE_MIGRATION_V33.sql and configure the v33 Stripe environment variables before enabling paid plans.